Most authors don’t make enough from their writing to pay for decent haircuts. (That’s why most of us look disheveled.). Sure, Malcolm Gladwell, Stephen Covey, and Danielle Steele live high off the hog on royalties, but most authors are rewarded with credibility, fan mail, and good reviews. By those standards, today was payday.
Seeing the “Educational Economy” More Clearly
March 3, 2008
Review by Alex Kaufman, President, SelfReliant LLC, Redmond, WA
The value and ubiquity of informal learning is presented clearly and passionately by e-learning champion Jay Cross in this book. The notion of informal learning is very familiar, and most of us will understand immediately what Cross is getting at: every conversation, web site, conference, or collaborative enterprise tends to yield some new insight into the world. We are simply learning all the time.
The title of this review relates Cross’s notion to one of my own observations about ubiquitous learning – namely, the “educational economy”. Every one of these informal learning events is like a “transaction” in which some knowledge is shared, and in return the understanding or even reputation of the sharer is increased. The “real” educational economy, is very difficult to formalize, so what Cross would call “informal learning” is (to me at least) the portion of the educational economy that we have had trouble accrediting or otherwise keeping tabs on socially. Formal learning describes those artificial mechanisms, such as courses, (which Cross loudly proclaims are dead), that are easy to keep tabs on and can yield some educational benefit.
Informal Learning is, at its heart, a book rich with discussion of how we learn best, and what situations contribute to organic, self-driven learning – particularly in the workplace, but the ideas presented are really universal. Jay appropriately spends time discussing how the Internet has become the ultimate self-education tool, pointing out that “…my son and his peers [learn] everything from homework assignments to network administration on the Web. [That's] also where he learned a lot more than his dad ever did about meteorology, PERL, San Francisco politics, environmental action groups, obscure singers, and much more…”
I’d like to sum up here just by sharing a quote from the book that I included on SR’s website: “Many learners today are not self-directed; they are waiting for directions. It’s time to tell them that the rules have changed. It’s in their self-interest to become proactive learning opportunists.”
This morning I began writing Informal Learning 2.0. I’ll keep you informed.










{ 1 trackback }
{ 8 comments… read them below or add one }
I had to smile at the last paragraph of Kaufman’s review, since I read this post immediately after making my own contribution to this month’s Big Question, in which I include the words “sadly, I have to admit that few audiences seem ready to assume the mantle of this approach, accustomed as they are to “being told”, but we can’t use that as an excuse.”
Great review. I read Informal Learning several months ago and I can now put it into better perspective. I loved it when I read it but I can tell you that the insights have actually grown deeper for me since that time.
It’s tremendous to hear that you are working on IL 2.0. I look forward to it.
Ken Carroll
Kudos, Jay.
Nothing like “formal” recognition.
Well-earned.
Looking forward to seeing you speak in NYC on 3/25.
Keep up the great work. It’s appreciated.
Joe Wehr
Jay,
I read Informal Learning last May. I appreciated it right away, it affirmed so many of the things I think about but hadn’t put them together in the same way you were able to.
Nine months later, I look back and see how reading your book was the start of a totally new way of intersecting with learning. I behave differently now on a day to day basis. And I facilitate in new ways. It took a while to allow it to all sink in and for me to realign my own activities.
Thanks for continuing to inspire me. Can’t wait to see what you do next.
Great review Jay, I read Informal Learning about a year ago and I cant wait to see 2.0. It was very informative and gave off a good vibe. It is a good source of inspiration.
Hi Jay,
I just wanted to thank you for republishing this review here – what an honor! I also appreciate your link back to the SelfReliant site. Ultimately, SR is all about acknowledging this organic, informal learning that is a natural part of the human experience, and finding innovative ways to catalyze it, enrich it, and accredit it – with finer and finer granularity.
My idea is that “microventures” are an emerging focal point for education, because they are both financially and intellectually productive. The course-driven model has narrow time horizons, and so it fails to give students the chance to find meaning in their own ideas or projects. Online platforms give you the opportunity to be an amateur “everything” – film director (YouTube), encyclopedia editor(Wikipedia), book publisher (Lulu), marketing director (Google AdSense), retailer (eBay), banker (Prosper) – and the list goes on.
I’ll be updating that site soon, and likely moving it to another address – please visit sometime if you feel so inclined
Thanks again,
Alex Kaufman
Founder, SelfReliant LLC
Blush.
Jay:
I’d add my thunderous applause but you already know I think the book is great and – staring at it right now in my bookshelf above my computer … listening to Glen Miller and Orchestra playing The Wabash Blues … looking forward to the next version … please keep me informed.
David